Call Now

Call Us 24/7 For A FREE Consultation

Winter Park Slip and Fall Lawyer

Hurt in a slip and fall in Winter Park? The store, restaurant, landlord or property manager that let the hazard sit can be held responsible for what the fall has cost you. Winter Park slip and fall lawyer David B. Datny represents people injured on wet floors, loose mats, broken pavement and poorly lit stairs, from the boutiques on Park Avenue to the big-box stores along Orlando Avenue and the apartment communities near Rollins College.

Before dedicating his practice exclusively to representing injured people, David B. Datny was a litigation partner at a large national insurance defense firm, defending insurers and their insureds. That experience gives him firsthand insight into how premises liability claims are investigated, evaluated, and defended—and how to build a strong case for his injured clients. For nearly a decade, he has represented injured individuals throughout the Winter Park area, pursuing claims under Florida premises liability law.

Call 407-753-7474 to talk with a Winter Park slip and fall attorney before you give the property’s insurer a statement. Your consultation is FREE, you pay nothing unless we recover compensation, and help is available 24/7 by phone or chat.

Fell at a store, restaurant or apartment in Winter Park? Talk with David today.

Call 407-753-7474 Chat Now Free Case Review

Winter Park slip and fall lawyer David B. Datny beside a spilled drink on a restaurant floor

Where Slip and Fall Accidents Happen in Winter Park

Winter Park packs a lot of foot traffic into a small city. Shoppers, diners, students and residents share the same entryways, aisles and parking lots, and when a business lets a spill, a broken paver or a dark stairwell go unaddressed, someone gets hurt. These are the places where we see falls most often.

Park Avenue

Boutiques, galleries and sidewalk cafés line Park Avenue, and outdoor tables crowd the walkways. Spilled drinks, rain-slick entryways after afternoon storms and uneven pavers outside storefronts cause many of the falls we see downtown.

Winter Park Village

The open-air center off Orlando Avenue mixes restaurants, a movie theater and shops around busy parking areas. Responsibility there is often split among the center’s owner, its management company and the individual tenants.

Orlando Avenue (US 17-92)

Supermarkets and big-box retailers line this corridor. Leaking coolers, produce on the floor, freshly mopped aisles and cluttered garden centers are some of the most common hazards.

Aloma and Fairbanks Plazas

Strip centers, coffee shops and fast-food restaurants along Aloma Avenue and near the Fairbanks Avenue exit off I-4 see steady in-and-out traffic, with greasy floors, wet restrooms and worn mats at the door.

Apartments and Condominiums

Communities near Rollins College, along Lakemont Avenue and in nearby Baldwin Park have stairwells, breezeways, lobbies and walkways that the owner or association must keep safe.

Parking Lots and Walkways

Potholes, broken curbs, loose wheel stops and dark corners in shopping center lots cause serious trip and falls. The property owner or its management company usually controls the lot, not the store you were visiting.

We see the same hazards in neighboring Maitland, Winter Springs, Casselberry and Altamonte Springs, and we represent fall victims throughout Orange and Seminole counties. Wherever you fell, the owner, tenant or management company in charge of that space had a duty to find and fix the hazard. Figuring out which one it was, and who handles its claims, is the next step.

Slip and Fall Accidents at Major Retailers in Winter Park

We handle injury claims involving major retailers throughout Florida, including Publix, Home Depot, Lowe’s, Costco, and Walmart, as well as restaurants and coffee shops such as Dunkin’ and P.F. Chang’s.

David has firsthand experience handling claims against these major retailers, including Publix injury cases in Winter Park. He understands how their claims operations work and knows who will be on the other end of the phone.

Store Who handles customer injury claims
Home Depot Sedgwick, a third-party claims administrator
Lowe’s Sedgwick
Family Dollar Sedgwick
Costco Gallagher Bassett (Costco is self-insured)
Publix Publix’s own claims department
Walmart Walmart’s own claims organization
Dollar General Dollar General’s own claims department

These representatives work for the company, not for you. Expect a friendly call, a request for a recorded statement or a medical authorization, and sometimes a quick offer of a small check, store credit or a gift card. Publix in particular often reaches out within days, weekends included. Accepting an early offer usually means signing a release that ends the claim, often before anyone knows whether you need surgery.

Already heard from a store’s claims representative? Call David at 407-753-7474 before you return that call.

Florida Slip and Fall Rules That Shape Your Claim

Insurers lean on the same few Florida rules in nearly every slip and fall case, so it pays to know them before anyone starts asking you questions.

Florida rule What it means for your claim
Spills inside a business
(§ 768.0755, Fla. Stat.)
For a fall on a spill, dropped food or tracked-in water inside a store or restaurant, you must show the business knew or should have known about it. How long it sat there, or proof that the same problem keeps coming back, can establish that knowledge.
Other dangerous conditions Broken flooring, loose mats, bad lighting and uneven walkways fall under Florida’s general premises liability rules. Owners must keep the property reasonably safe and warn visitors about dangers that are not obvious.
Comparative fault
(§ 768.81(6), Fla. Stat.)
Your recovery is reduced by your share of fault and barred if you are found more than 50 percent at fault. Expect the insurer to blame your shoes, your phone or an “open and obvious” hazard.
Two-year deadline
(§ 95.11(5)(a), Fla. Stat.)
For falls after March 24, 2023, most negligence lawsuits must be filed within two years. Talking with an adjuster does not stop that clock.

Each of those rules turns on proof, and the strongest proof in a fall case tends to disappear first.

Evidence That Proves a Slip and Fall Claim

Video gets recorded over, spills get mopped and broken steps get repaired, so the evidence in a fall case has a short shelf life. These are the records that most often decide who is responsible:

  • Surveillance video of the fall and the minutes before it
  • The store or property incident report
  • Sweep logs and inspection schedules
  • Maintenance and repair records
  • Photos of the hazard and the surrounding area
  • Names and phone numbers of witnesses
  • The shoes and clothing you were wearing
  • Medical records from your first visit

Before a lawsuit, we send preservation demands asking the property owner and its insurer to keep video, reports and records. If the case goes to litigation, we request them in discovery. Your own photos and witness names matter just as much, and our Florida slip and fall checklist and our guide to what to photograph after a store accident explain what to capture.

If you were hurt, get checked the same day. AdventHealth Winter Park on Lakemont Avenue has an emergency department, and urgent care or your own doctor can see you for less serious injuries. Tell the provider exactly how you fell.

Talk with a Winter Park slip and fall lawyer before you talk to the insurer.

Free consultation · No fee unless we win · Available 24/7 · Se habla español

Call 407-753-7474 Chat Now Free Case Review

With the evidence protected and your treatment documented, the focus shifts to what the fall has cost you.

What Compensation Can You Get After a Winter Park Slip and Fall?

A fall onto tile or concrete can break a hip or wrist, tear a knee or shoulder, injure the back or neck, or cause a concussion, and recovery often takes months. Florida law lets an injured person recover for the full range of those losses.

Damages You Can Claim After a Fall

  • Hospital, surgery and therapy bills
  • Future medical care
  • Lost wages and reduced earning ability
  • Pain and suffering
  • Mental anguish and lost enjoyment of life
  • Scarring or permanent injury

We fight for maximum compensation and advise against settling until your doctors know whether you need surgery and what your recovery will look like.

Results in Premises Liability Cases

These recoveries come from fall and premises cases handled by The Datny Law Firm.

$152,500

Sidewalk trip and fall that left a client with several non-surgical injuries.

$125,000

Slip and fall that led to knee surgery.

$125,000

Premises case in which the client needed shoulder surgery.

Every case is different, and past results do not guarantee a similar outcome. See more on our case results page.

Why Winter Park Fall Victims Choose David

After a fall, you need someone who will protect the evidence, handle the store’s claims team and keep you informed while you heal. Here is what working with a Winter Park premises liability attorney at The Datny Law Firm looks like.

Local Experience

David has represented accident victims in Winter Park and Central Florida since founding his firm. We combine local experience with personal injury legal knowledge to effectively pursue injury claims for our clients.

Insurance Defense Insight

As a defense litigation partner, David represented insurers and self-insured retailers. He knows the arguments a store will make about your fall because he once made them.

Store Claims Know-How

From Publix and Home Depot to Lowe’s, Costco and Walmart, David has handled store injury claims throughout Florida and knows how each company’s claims team operates.

Flexibility

If you cannot meet at our Winter Park location, we can often arrange for our investigator to visit you at home, in the hospital, or another convenient location. We also offer virtual meetings by Zoom, FaceTime, WhatsApp, or phone, along with electronic document signing, making the process convenient without sacrificing personal attention.

Straight to Your Lawyer

Every client has direct access to David by phone, email and text message, backed by a dedicated paralegal who keeps the day-to-day details moving.

Hablamos Español

Our paralegal speaks Spanish, and we arrange Creole and Russian interpreters when needed, so nothing about your case gets lost in translation.

There is no fee unless we win, and the answers below cover the questions Winter Park fall victims ask us most.

Frequently Asked Questions: Slip and Fall Accidents in Winter Park

How long do I have to file a slip and fall claim in Florida?

For falls after March 24, 2023, most slip and fall lawsuits must be filed within two years of the fall under § 95.11(5)(a), Fla. Stat. Falls before that date generally had four years. Video and witnesses are often gone long before either deadline, so it pays to act early.

If I was partly at fault, can I still recover?

Yes, as long as you are not found more than 50 percent at fault. Under § 768.81(6), Fla. Stat., your compensation is reduced by your percentage of fault, so a client found 20 percent at fault recovers 80 percent of the damages. Above 50 percent, recovery is barred.

Do I need a lawyer for my Winter Park slip and fall case?

Yes. Stores such as Home Depot, Publix, Lowe’s and Walmart defend these claims through experienced adjusters and defense lawyers. A lawyer preserves the evidence, proves how long the hazard was there, handles every call with the claims representatives and protects you from early offers that undervalue your injuries.

Can I bring a claim if I fell at my Winter Park apartment complex?

Yes. Landlords and management companies must maintain common areas such as stairways, breezeways, walkways and parking lots. These claims usually go through the owner’s liability insurer, and reporting the fall to management in writing gives you a dated record.

Where would my Winter Park slip and fall lawsuit be filed?

A lawsuit over a fall in Winter Park or Maitland is generally filed in Orange County, part of Florida’s Ninth Judicial Circuit, at the Orange County Courthouse in downtown Orlando. Falls in Winter Springs, Casselberry and Altamonte Springs are in Seminole County, where the Eighteenth Judicial Circuit holds court in Sanford. Many claims resolve before a lawsuit is ever filed.

How long does a Winter Park slip and fall case take to resolve?

It depends mostly on your medical treatment and whether the insurer disputes liability. Many claims resolve within months after treatment ends, while cases that require a lawsuit in Orange County take longer. A claim should not be valued until your doctors know the full extent of your injuries.

How much is my Winter Park slip and fall case worth?

Value depends on the severity of your injuries, the treatment you need, lost income, any lasting effects and the strength of the liability evidence. Insurers often try to close claims early and cheaply, so get a full evaluation before accepting anything. For a free consultation with our Winter Park slip and fall lawyer, call 407-753-7474.

Speak With a Winter Park Slip and Fall Lawyer Today

The property’s insurer starts building its defense the day a fall is reported. If you were hurt at a store, restaurant, apartment complex or shopping center in Winter Park, call 407-753-7474 to reach our Winter Park slip and fall lawyer directly, or chat with us now. Your consultation is FREE, there is no fee unless we win, and we are available 24/7.

Hurt in a different way? Visit our Winter Park personal injury lawyer page, or our Winter Park car accident lawyer page if you were in a crash. If your fall happened at a store elsewhere in the Orlando area, our Orlando Publix accident lawyer and Orlando Home Depot accident lawyer pages cover those claims.

Call 407-753-7474 Chat Now

Attorney David B. Datny

About the Author

David B. Datny, Esq. — Founder, The Datny Law Firm

David B. Datny has practiced law for more than 18 years in New York and Florida, on both sides of personal injury litigation. As a litigation partner at a large national insurance defense firm, he represented insurance companies and self-insured retailers. He then changed sides and now proudly represents only injured accident victims. From the firm’s Winter Park office on Aloma Avenue, David handles slip and fall and premises liability claims involving supermarkets, home improvement stores, restaurants, shopping centers and apartment communities across Central Florida.

Admitted in Florida and New York · Member, Florida Justice Association · Super Lawyers Rising Star · Life Member, Million Dollar Advocates Forum

Last updated November 2026 · Read David’s full attorney profile →

Call Now Button